Win by 10 vs NN. With no swing on this board where CHO defended amazingly well, a defense that would never have occurred to me, followed by NN and I misdefending to set it only 1.
Bidding the same at both tables. I’ve wondered. Do all of you respond 1H rather than 1D with 4-4 in the reds? Do bots?
Anyway, we’re defending 2D so of course we lead the stiff in partner’s suit. CHO wins, and shifts to K and another trump. Probably the right defense , but I think it would be easy for a human to miss. We pull trumps. and with only hearts and spades left, how did NN and I each misdefend? We led the heart 10, ducked in dummy. Partner won king, of course, it was the setting trick and if declarer had the Q this might be making if he ducked. Had we led the Q, defense is easy.
Far more imps at stake on this one: 7NT, where you can see at trick 1 that you’re going to have to find the club Q unless in a miracle the J10 of diamonds both drop in the first 3 rounds. Or, not as good odds as a club finesse, but not terrible, you could play for a club diamond squeeze. Or maybe it is as good. Pretty close.
Anyway, we each took 10 side tricks, the diamond J10 not both falling, I happened to guess the club right, to win 10 imps.
The interesting question is whether he and I each missed an easy make. After winning the heart opening lead in our hand, what about immediately playing the club jack from hand, rising with the club ace if not covered. You still have the chance of picking up J10 or J10x of diamonds, and just take the club hook through RHO if they don’t fall. Almost, though not quite, as good a line if LHO would never cover the club J, and making the contract whenever he does cover.
[the “not quite as good” is because by playing the other suits first, you might get distributional information that LHO is more likely to have the club Q.]
Reissued