Thatās bad news!
Are you saying that masks are never useful, regardless of type and situation? If masks completely ceased to exist, no problem, that COVID has revealed weāve been pwned by Big Mask all this time?
Specifically to COVID, if your kid was in close contact with someone with COVID, and you could choose whether one or both of them were masked or not, would you not bother with masking, because any masks wouldnāt do jack squat and your kid is going to be fine and will keep their COVID germs to themselves anyway?
1 Like
Is there any one of those 70+ references you find particularly compelling? Or is it just that someone on Twitter compiled a list of articles that referenced masks?
2 Likes
Each of the āpointsā has several references. Usually the first one and sometimes the last one are actual research/data, although they tend not to be super-supportive of the āpointā. Most of the rest of the references are just opinion pieces in the press.
At least, thatās what I got from reviewing the first several āpointsā.
Thatās what I concluded as well.
@Marcie - I found some people you should follow on social media if you have not already:
1 Like
The most interesting link I found was this one
XM Dashboard | Qualtrics Experience Management
(I posted it above, too, but I think itās worth itās own post.)
It collected data from a large number of school, and tagged them all by what grades they include (elementary, middle, high) and whether they were being measured at a time when their community had low, medium, or high background transmission.
It also tagged the schools for whether they required masks, whether they improved ventilation, whether they had people distance (no, 3ā, 6ā) and whether they operated at reduced capacity.
You need to filter by grade, because thereās enough bias in which mitigations tend to be done by grade (and older kids are much more likely to catch and spread covid than younger kids) that otherwise the bias overcomes the data. But if you do so, itās quite interesting.
Far and away the most useful intervention is masking ā to protect teachers. Thereās a strong effect at every grade level, and at every background infection level beyond ālowā that teachers are more likely to test positive if the kids arenāt wearing masks.
They are much less protective for the kids, and in some cases, kids wearing masks were slightly more likely to become infected. I suspect this is because kids were sloppy about handling their masks and about touching their eyes. If I were a parent looking at this data, I would push for masks in the school when infection levels were higher than the ālowā level, and Iād also teach my kid about how to handle a mask and to avoid touching his eyes and nose while at school (unless heās just washed his hands carefully.)
Itās funny that it showed up in an anti-maskerās tweet. My guess is that the tweeter was more concerned with finding a lot of references than with actually reading them.
1 Like
I wasnāt following any of them (your article only names 1 of the āDisinformation Dozenā but I found the list elsewhere)
I started from the end, but similar impression.
Do most schools have windows that open? I though that one of the things being done to improve HVAC energy efficiency was to make buildings about as airtight as possible.
Regardless, now with A/C or heat running, they want to open the windows?
The PDF of the report was linked in the article. 
2 Likes
I donāt know what thread this is appropriate for besides the one about ending your sentence in a preposition, but itās about school and vaccines, so I choose you.
Indiana Universityās vaccine requirement should stand, federal judge rules - NPR
1 Like
School district is requiring masks for all (except for some medical conditions) in the fall. In person learning is too important, delta is on the rampage, and the vaccination percentage is low, so even the vaccinated have to wear a mask until people start being more responsible and cases arenāt spreading so much.
Knowing that people lie about their status, Iām glad about this policy. Glad my sons will be in person five days a week.
4 Likes
Weāre counting down the days until 11 year-olds can be vaccinated.
4 Likes
Do they require a birth certificate? If I had an 11 year-old that would be in a school with mostly older youth, Iād be tempted to fudge the birth date and get them vaccinated.
When I was trying to get myself vaccinated and my turn was coming up but hadnāt happened yet, what I found was that the health systems and CVS, all of which used MyChart, you never even entered your DOB. They knew who you were, knew your age. Now whether they allowed you to register if they hadnāt yet hit your age group but would between now & the appointment varied. But you never input your DOB to have a chance to lie.
For places like the grocery store pharmacies that werenāt part of a pharmacy chain and the mass vaccinations at the sports arenas then you did input a DOB and thus had an opportunity to lie. For adults they checked IDs but 12 year olds donāt have them so it would be admittedly difficult to distinguish between an 11 and a 12 year old.
Yeah, Samās Club, where Iām going, had me input my DOB, Iāll find out how closely they check my id when I go get jabbed. I imagine you might have a problem when Samās bills your insurance for the jab fee they get to charge and your insurance denies it because the kid doesnāt qualify for a shot.
I thought about that. At that point your kid has the shot though. I wonder what youād have to pay OOP?
For the vaccines that require two doses that could be an issue getting the second shot.
When does this kid turn 12? I assume you could schedule the first shot to be on their 12th birthday.
My niece is only 6, so thereās really no passing her off as 12. Once 6-year-olds qualify that will be the whole family. 
In my state, the vaccination sites were explicitly not allowed to require ID. They asked for it. And they asked for insurance info. And if you didnāt have either, they were instructed to jab you anyway. (And the state picks up the tab where insurance doesnāt.)
Yes, the goal was to make sure that vaccines were available to the indigent and undocumented. After all, they interact with the rest of us, and they count towards our herd immunity, and vaccinating them makes the rest of us that much safer.
Of course, if you already told them who you are, they probably know who your daughter is, too. Iād probably just try to get her the first shot on or close to her 12th birthday.
They will likely ask your 11 year old for their birthday, so if you can convince your kid to lie when asked you might be able to get by.
pretty easy to just say you donāt have insurance. i never bothered to give them my insurance info when i got the vaccine. it isnāt needed.