Had missed this thread. Apologies.
A: Pass. Maybe I try to be too coy on these, but without support for partner, and with RHO having spades, I think it may be unlikely either side has a fit. So tempted to let them hang themselves and leave them underestimating me. Is that a bad mindset?
B: 2C. Seems enough to show basic support for partner’s suit and my moderate level of strength.
C: Pass. This might be too conservative. But this feels like we will rarely have enough for game. Sure, I can imagine it. But I imagine us going down more often than not. And my hand may have some defensive value if Opps decide to jump in.
D: Double. I was thinking 2D with the basic 2/1 requirements, but I like double slightly better because it allows me to show my 4 spades at a cheaper spot.
E: Double? Not even entirely sure if this would imply for penalty or takeout. It feels like we should get a plus score here. Partner knows I have 5 hearts and 3 spades. Pass would be my other consideration.
F: 3NT. May just gamble with 3NT. Spades is a big risk, but West has to lead. Not being able to access any help from partner may also be a problem. But I likely have 9 NT tricks myself as long as I can stop spades (assuming west doesn’t open with a spade lead.
G: 3NT. I’m unsure, but 2NT is likely invitational and may let partner pass, but I think we have enough to play in 3NT. Obviously we likely have no fit at all with partner and that could become a problem. But hoping we have enough individual strength to carry.
H: D4. My initial thought is to try to knock out East’s ability to access West’s diamond power. Maybe I am off base. 4D=Natural makes me nervous that it doesn’t imply diamond length and weakness, but rather diamond length and strength??
From VVV by e-mail