Bridge: MSC 2025 Discussion

A. 4N
B. 4C
C. Double
D. 3C
E. 3C
F. Double
G. 4S
H. Spade 10

A) 4C. If 4NT is definitely RKC, I would pick that, but think 4NT might be natural?
B) 4C. I don’t think it is a good bid, but every else seems worse.
C) 3H. Tempted by double, planning to convert to 3H, but if opps bid more spades, that will be no good.
D) 2H I guess? MPs is a weird game.
E) 3 clubs. 2NT ok, but with partner a passed hand, losses some of the appeal to me.
F) Double. Partner a passed hand makes a jump in diamonds less likely. Will be 3NT over 3D, 3 spades over 3 hearts.
G) 6 diamonds. Everything is too ambiguous, will just bid what I think is the best contract. Probably won’t score well in a contest.
H) Jack of diamonds. Only thing I could up with for choosing between the minors is that LHO might have bid stayman with 4441 (or similar) but not 4414.

                              A     B     C     D     E     F     G     H
procrastinator                4C    4C    3H    2H    3C   Dbl    6D    DJ
oirg                          4N    4C   Dbl    3C    3C   Dbl    4S   S10
SW                            4C    5D    3N    3S    3C    4S    6H    DJ
Klaymen                                                                 
ST                                                                      
BTDT                          4C    4C    3H    3S     P    4S    6D    H6
NN                            4C    4C    3H    3S     P    3N    4S    DJ
veni vidi vici                                                          
4Sigma                                                                  
Abstract Actuary                                                        
Leading                       4C    4C    3H    3S    3C                DJ

Last chance to influence the voting. I must submit this evening. In the absence of further discussion, I would submit Dbl on F and 6D on G (my initial first choice, and what would be my clear first choice at imps)

From ST via e-mail

There was another e-mail indicating some ambiguity about C. I think Dbl was final preference, but possibly he wanted 3H.

                              A     B     C     D     E     F     G     H
procrastinator                4C    4C    3H    2H    3C   Dbl    6D    DJ
oirg                          4N    4C   Dbl    3C    3C   Dbl    4S   S10
SW                            4C    5D    3N    3S    3C    4S    6H    DJ
ST                            4C    5D   Dbl    3C    2N    3N    4S   S10
BTDT                          4C    4C    3H    3S     P    4S    6D    H6
NN                            4C    4C    3H    3S     P    3N    4S    DJ
Submitted                     4C    4C    3H    3S    3C   Dbl    4S    DJ

F ended in an exact tie. G ended in a virtual tie, but those who wanted to bid a slam now didn’t agree on which slam.

                  A        B        C        D        E        F        G        H        Total
procrastinator    4C   100 4C   100 3H   60  2H   30  3C   90  Dbl  100 6D   50  DJ   100 630  
oirg              4N   40  4C   100 Dbl  100 3C   70  3C   90  Dbl  100 4S   100 S10  30  630  
SW                4C   100 5D   0   3N   80  3S   30  3C   90  4S   50  6H   10  DJ   100 460  
Klaymen                                                                                        
BTDT              4C   100 4C   100 3H   60  3S   30  P    70  4S   50  6D   50  H6   0   460  
NN                4C   100 4C   100 3H   60  3S   30  P    70  3N   50  4S   100 DJ   100 610  
veni vidi vici                                                                                 
Submitted         4C   100 4C   100 3H   60  3S   30  3C   90  Dbl  100 4S   100 DJ   100 680  


                                                                               
                  4C   100 4C   100 Dbl  100 2D   100 2N   100 Dbl  100 4S   100 CJ   100   
                  4N   40  5D   0   3N   80  3C   70  3C   90  3N   50  6D   50  DJ   100      
                                    3H   60  2H   30  P    70  4S   50  6H   10  S10  30       
                                             3S   30                             H6   0        
                                                                                               

Fortunately we got 100 on each of the questions which had been tied, so our Submitted score of 680 tied for 37-44 on the monthly honor roll. 62 people made the honor roll, which required 650.

A) Dbl
B) 2H
C) 3C
D) 4S
E) 5C
F) Pass
G) 3N
H) Diamond 6

A) X
B) 3S
C) 3S
D) 4S
E) 6N
F) Pass
G) 3N
H) s9

March guesses:

A. 2H
B. 4S
C. 3S
D. 2D
E. 5C
F. 3C
G. 3N
H. Spade 9

From ST by e-mail

From VVV by e-mail

A. 3D. Since it’s imps, and my diamonds are better and spades maybe not as good as double would suggest
B. 2S. Normally I would bid 2H with this much, and would here if vul, but the heart Q may be worthless especially if partner declares
C. 3S. Suit a bit weak, but values fine
D. 4S. Tough choice since 4H may be much better.
E. 5H, even though pass may be better (or 6D might be, or 6NT)
F. 2H. With only 2 hearts and only 4 spades, not going to bid more now
G. 3NT. Hard to imagine anything else
H. HQ. Nothing attractive; start to unblock

                              A     B     C     D     E     F     G     H
procrastinator                                                          
oirg                          2H    4S    3S    2D    5C    3C    3N    S9
SW                            3D    2S    3S    4S    5H    2H    3N    HQ
ST                            DBL    2S    3H    3D    5C    3D    3N    D6
BTDT                          Dbl    2H    3C    4S    5C     P    3N    D6
NN                                                                      
veni vidi vici                2H    2H    3H    3D    6D     P    3D   C10
Leading                       Dbl          3S    4S    5C     P    3N      
                              A     B     C     D     E     F     G     H
procrastinator                                                          
oirg                          2H    4S    3S    2D    5C    3C    3N    S9
SW                            3D    2S    3S    4S    5H    2H    3N    HQ
Klaymen                       Dbl    3S    3S    4S    6N     P    3N    S9
ST                            DBL    2S    3H    3D    5C    3D    3N    D6
BTDT                          Dbl    2H    3C    4S    5C     P    3N    D6
NN                                                                      
veni vidi vici                2H    2H    3H    3D    6D     P    3D   C10
Leading                       Dbl          3S    4S    5C     P    3N      

Klaymen’s votes had been included in determining the Leading, but the row had been hidden for printing.

NN by e-mail

A. 2 clubs. Borderline, but if I can show a strong raise without raising the level more than a single raise, think it is ok. If we have game in spades, will be hearing more from pd.
B. 4 spades. Am I missing something?
C. 2NT. Yuck.
D. 2 diamonds. If partner bids hearts will bid the heart game. Otherwise will bid 4 spades.
E. 6 diamonds. Hope partner has a black ace.
F. Pass. Big gamble, but seems somewhat likely we don’t have a game
G. 3NT. No second choice, not even sure what other call I am supposed to consider?
H. Ten of clubs.

procrastinator via e-mail

                              A     B     C     D     E     F     G     H
procrastinator                2C    4S    2N    2D    6D     P    3N   C10
oirg                          2H    4S    3S    2D    5C    3C    3N    S9
SW                            3D    2S    3S    4S    5H    2H    3N    HQ
Klaymen                       Dbl    3S    3S    4S    6N     P    3N    S9
ST                            DBL    2S    3H    3D    5C    3D    3N    D6
BTDT                          Dbl    2H    3C    4S    5C     P    3N    D6
NN                            2C    2H    3S    3S    6D    3S    3N   C10
veni vidi vici                2H    2H    3H    3D    6D     P    3D   C10
Submitted                     Dbl    2H    3S    4S    6D     P    3N   C10

Since all regulars had voted, I submitted, breaking the tie on E.

                  A        B        C        D        E        F        G        H        Total
procrastinator    2C   60  4S   100 2N   80  2D   100 6D   100 P    100 3N   100 C10  90  730  
oirg              2H   60  4S   100 3S   60  2D   100 5C   0   3C   60  3N   100 S9   100 580  
SW                3D   0   2S   60  3S   60  4S   70  5H   0   2H   0   3N   100 HQ   60  350  
Klaymen           Dbl  100 3S   90  3S   60  4S   70  6N   70  P    100 3N   100 S9   100 690  
ST                DBL  100 2S   60  3H   80  3D   90  5C   0   3D   70  3N   100 D6   70  570  
BTDT              Dbl  100 2H   80  3C   60  4S   70  5C   0   P    100 3N   100 D6   70  580  
NN                2C   60  2H   80  3S   60  3S   20  6D   100 3S   90  3N   100 C10  90  600  
veni vidi vici    2H   60  2H   80  3H   80  3D   90  6D   100 P    100 3D   70  C10  90  670  
Submitted         Dbl  100 2H   80  3S   60  4S   70  6D   100 P    100 3N   100 C10  90  700  


                                                                               
                  Dbl  100 4S   100 2S   100 2D   100 6D   100 P    100 3N   100 S9   100   
                  2D   80  3S   90  3H   80  3D   90  6N   70  3S   90  3D   70  C10  90       
                  2C   60  2H   80  2N   80  4S   70  5H   0   3D   70           D6   70       
                  2H   60  2S   60  3C   60  3H   50  5C   0   3C   60           HQ   60       
                  3D   0            3S   60  3S   20           2H   0                          

procrastinator’s 730 would tie for 6-9 on the monthly honor roll. Our 700 did tie for 30-42. It took 690 to make the honor roll (56 people did).