20Q Game 22

I wonder if it’s light.

That’s a hell no on weight. But I might call that larger than a shoebox.

Maybe a soul? That might be neight larger nor smaller than a shoebox, not having any physical size.

Kinda goes against #2, #10 and #11

Hmm, would you consider a soul to be “man made”?

Maybe it’s a lie, or a story, or an aphorism.

I’m not sure it can be “seen”, but I’m not sure how VA would define “soul”.

Could possibly be something like “love”, but I might have problems with some of the answers if it is.

I don’t think VA would say a soul is man-made.

it stays put while in use guys.

That fits with “lie”, etc.

Yeah - I’m having trouble figuring out how something that isn’t a physical object “stays put while in use”.

Moods linger in a room, that could be “staying put”?

It also has to kinda, sorta, be able to be seen. I guess something like a mood would work for that. Is a mood bigger than a shoe box?

Is it an emotion or feeling?

[quote=“Vorian_Atreides, post:40, topic:1997, full:true”]

Q# Poster Question Answer
1 A_Student Is it organic? No
2 Lucy Is it man-made? Yes
3 MayanActuary Is it typically found indoors? Yes
4 John.S.Mill Does it have a smell (odor)? No
5 A_Student Is it bigger than a men’s size 12 shoe box? No
6 MayanActuary Does it use electricity? No
7 soyleche Does it weigh more than an apple? Hell NO!
8 twig93 Is it made primarily of metal? No
9 twig93 Would a typical house have at least one of these? Yes*
10 Lucy Does it stay put while in use? Yes
** ************ Clue: It's not a physical object. **************
11 A_Student Is it in a person’s body? Yes, in a manner of speaking (see Q9 for example)
12 soyleche Can it be seen? Yes, in a manner of speaking (not related to Q9, BTW)
13 MayanActuary Is it an emotion or feeling? No
14 ?? y/n

*But not in the way that you’re likely asking.

Next clue forthcoming after the after the 15th and 19th questions as well.

 I am finding the discussion fun.  I hope y'all are finding it fun as well.

Unofficial: I kinda want to ask if it interacts with physical objects - but I’m not sure how that would be interpreted. For example - does a thought interact with physical objects (like the brain)?

Unofficial: Maybe we need to go meta - could it be “a guess in a 20 questions game”?

If I wanted to learn more about this, would I be better off going to a psychologist than a physicist?

1 Like
Q# Poster Question Answer
1 A_Student Is it organic? No
2 Lucy Is it man-made? Yes
3 MayanActuary Is it typically found indoors? Yes
4 John.S.Mill Does it have a smell (odor)? No
5 A_Student Is it bigger than a men’s size 12 shoe box? No
6 MayanActuary Does it use electricity? No
7 soyleche Does it weigh more than an apple? Hell NO!
8 twig93 Is it made primarily of metal? No
9 twig93 Would a typical house have at least one of these? Yes*
10 Lucy Does it stay put while in use? Yes
** ************ Clue: It's not a physical object. **************
11 A_Student Is it in a person’s body? Yes, in a manner of speaking (see Q9 for example)
12 soyleche Can it be seen? Yes, in a manner of speaking (not related to Q9, BTW)
13 MayanActuary Is it an emotion or feeling? No
14 A_Student If I wanted to learn more about this, would I be better off going to a psychologist than a physicist? No
15 ?? y/n

*But not in the way that you’re likely asking.

Next clue forthcoming after the after the 15th and 19th questions as well.

A_Student should have made this official to begin with:

Is it imaginary?

Unofficial: what about music? Might have issues with #10 and sorta works with #12 if you count looking at sheet music.